High Protein Cheesecake Cups

507 Flares 507 Flares ×

A friend of mine once called cheesecake the “Holy Grail of Desserts.” In my mind this recipe is a sort of holy grail in that it is has all of the best recipe characteristics: easy, fast (no-bake!), requires just a few ingredients, low in carbs/sugar/calories, and the end result tastes…. incredible. It’s that simple.

Top your cheesecakes any way you like! With strawberies, jam, a squiggle of Hershey’s Light syrup (my favorite!) or a drizzle of honey.

I suggest using Friendship brand cottage cheese and Philadelphia brand cream cheese. Here’s why: in the first case, Friendship’s product is smoother (blends faster) and is lower in carbs. While most full-fat cream cheeses taste equivalent in my opinion, when it comes to fat free or reduced fat- the Philly people are onto something. They do it better than any other brand I’ve tried.

If you’ve never used unflavored gelatin before, you’ll find it right near Jell-o in the grocery store. It comes in small envelopes. Just tear one open and measure out 2 tsp.


  • 3 tsp unflavored gelatin (such as Knox)
  • 1/2 cup boiling water
  • 1 tsp vanilla
  • 16 ounces 1% cottage cheese
  • 1/4 cup fat free cream cheese (Philadelphia if possible)
  • 1/2 cup Splenda granulated (or 1/2 cup sugar or 12 packets of Equal, Truvia, or Splenda)


  • Stir together gelatin, Splenda and vanilla with boiling water in a small bowl. Place cottage cheese and cream cheese in a blender and pour gelatin mixture over. Cover. Process until completely smooth.
  • Pour cheesecake mixture into 12 foil cupcake liners and refrigerate 90 min -2 hrs (until firm to the touch). Peel away foil and enjoy.

Nutrition facts per serving:
40 calories
6 g protein
2 grams carbs
0 g fat
2 mg cholesterol
153 mg sodium
0 g fiber

Recipe by Registered Dietitian Georgie Fear, author of www.AskGeorgie.com. For more delicious, healthy ideas pick up her nutrition guide and cookbook for physique athletes, Fuel Up.

Top 50 Supplements
Advertise Here
  • test


  • KaizerSoze

    These are AH!mazing!!!

  • Karen S

    Iake these often. My friends come over and eat them all! They are that good! I used half the amount of truvia and they were perfect. I also make a strawberry sauce ontop with 4 strawberries chopped, boiled, strained, thickened & 1 teaspoon of truvia and near end of thickening add about two strawberries in chunks cook till soft. Tastes awesome. I used blueberries too for same type sauce.